A response to Rob Bell’s “Love Wins”

Here is a response posted by Marlin Bjornrud after reading Rob Bell’s new book “Love Wins”.  Now this book sparked a lot of controversy long before anyone ever read it.  We looked at this a little while back, check it out.   Marlin is an Oak Hills alumni and has been the pastor of the Evangelical Free Church in Embarrass for 30+ years.  (In full disclosure he is also my father)  Check out his“Coffee Messages”, a great little read as you enjoy a cup of coffee.


“Love Wins” first impressions

by Marlin Bjornrud on Wednesday, March 23, 2011 at 10:19am

Well, I just finished Rob Bell’s new book, “Love Wins”. Rob is most effective in his short Nooma videos, because he must present one truth in 13 minutes. When he has the opportunity to write an entire book, he tends to ask so many provocative questions and make so many provocative statements, that the final product is unclear, confusing, and open to tons of misunderstanding. Stick to the Nooma “shorts” Rob. That is your strength in teaching. In “love wins”, Rob seems to be practicing reductionism, in the sense that he speaks strongly and primarily about the love of God in a way that leaves the reader wondering if he has ever read, or is willing to acknowledge, the many scriptures that present the fact of God’s wrath. where is the “whole counsel of God” here? it’s like, “this is the kind of God people want and this is the kind of God people don’t want. so, I will give them the God they want.” Does Rob believe that there is a place of eternal torment called hell, or the lake of fire, or whatever, or is he just trying to give us the impression that he believes hell is what you experience here, if you reject God’s love? his lack of clarity is troubling. if you read the book, be careful, as you read the many references to the Hebrew language and culture, as the final word on what God meant in certain scriptures. it sounds convincing, but who says it’s accurate?… and then we have yet another use of the Luke 15 stories to present ideas that I don’t believe were initially intended by Jesus when He told them. the stories simply answered the critics’ complaints about Jesus hanging out with the lost. why do we think we can build all kinds of other teachings and theologies from them? finally, I would caution my friends to not conclude from this book that Rob Bell is a “universalist”. I can see how you could jump to that conclusion, but I am not certain that you would be accurate. Be careful. I applaud Rob for being so passionate about God’s love. We all should be. But in our passion for one truth, we shouldn’t reduce other truth to being almost non-existent, or even untrue. Let me know what you think about this: because of some harsh comments and sarcastic statements made in the book, I wonder if , second to a presentation about God’s love, Rob might have been taking a jab at those of us who believe that predestination, election, and God’s sovereign choice are actually taught in scripture in connection with salvation. These are only my initial thoughts. I would be interested in your thoughts, especially if you have read the book. Please, no conclusions, if you haven’t.



2 thoughts on “A response to Rob Bell’s “Love Wins”

  1. On this note, here is a review by Relevant Magazine of “Love Wins”. Check it out. In the post a few weeks ago about the initial response to this book (before it was released) we linked you to an Article by Relevant Magazine. I really respect how they refused to actually comment about the book itself, even though they had read an advanced copy, until others had the chance to read the book and intelligently join the conversation. Check out their full review here, http://www.relevantmagazine.com/culture/books/reviews/25070-love-wins-by-rob-bell

  2. Marlin- Thank you for your response to Rob Bell’s book. I’m only half way through, and I too applaud the excellent questions he rises and the focus on the vast love of God which surpasses knowledge. I do wish he would be looking more in depth at the scriptures which talk very pointedly about the wrath and judgements of God. I actually begin re-examining this whole topic (by studying scripture) before I knew anything about Rob’s book, and I wrote my own blog invited evangelicals to “join the conversation”. It’s unfortunate that there are so many alarmists in Christian circles that won’t even stop for a moment to humbly converse about this. I would love your comments on my blog. http://www.aliciamock.blogspot.com (I was a member of an EFree church in college..now I’m a 40 year old wife and mom of 4 kiddos- we attend a Vineyard Church) Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s